Our love affair was like a movie show So beautiful and true Each piece of love was wild and full of fire And the stars were me and you How could I know you found another guy The way you acted out your part And then you stayed away so many nights You knew then it would tear my heart apart Don't play that game with me Not that game with me Your love never, never, never will I share Don't play that game with me Not that game with me With that other, other guy, it's not fair You tried to tell me he was just a fling A little stop along the way But I can tell you it's something more than that In spite of all the things you say You've gotta choose between the two of us You gotta choose that guy or me I can't go on not knowing where I stand If you want him, then set me free Don't play that game with me Not that game with me Your love never, never, never will I share Don't play that game with me Not that game with me With that other, other guy, it's not fair I'm tired of all your lies You're playin' with me So stop your foolin' around I beg you, please Don't play that game with me Not that game with me Your love never, never will I share Don't play that game with me Not that game with me With that other guy, it's not fair Don't play that game with me Not that game with me Your love never, never will I share Don't play that game with me Not that game with me With that other guy, it's not fair