It Hurts Me:Bobby Sherman. #118 (Bubbling Under) BB Hot 100 on DECCA Records in 1965. #1. I never thought that I could cry the way I'm crying now. I never thought my heart would sigh the way it's sighing now. But ever since you left, my thoughts have been so blue. I'll never smile again, unless I smile with you. #2. As time goes by I find that I'm still thinking about you. I tried and tried, and even cried, but nothing seems to do. I even tell myself that soon I will forget. I find myself alone..I haven't forgotten you. It hurts me..oh, it hurts me. It hurts me to know that you're so happy in somebody else's arms. It hurts me. A sixties smash from Kraziekhat.